--- title: "November Event Recap: 5 Takeaways For Content Teams & SEO's" description: "November Event Recap: 5 Takeaways For Content Teams & SEO's" image: https://www.utahdmc.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Networking-at-SLC-SEM-1024x682.jpg --- [![Utah DIgital Marketing Collective](https://www.utahdmc.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Utah%20DMC%20Logo.png?width=175&height=175&name=Utah%20DMC%20Logo.png "Utah DIgital Marketing Collective")](https://www.utahdmc.org/) - [Home](https://www.utahdmc.org) - [Events](https://www.utahdmc.org/#events) - [New Online Events](https://www.utahdmc.org/online-events) - [Code of Conduct](https://www.utahdmc.org/code-of-conduct) - [About Us](https://www.utahdmc.org/#about) - [Contact Us](https://www.utahdmc.org/contact-us) - Slack - Jobs Board - Sponsors - Membership - [Blog](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog) # The Utah DMC Blog ## November Event Recap: 5 Takeaways For Content Teams & SEO's by [kacieeugenia819](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/author/kacieeugenia819), on Nov 16, 2011 5:30:16 PM On November 16, 2011, SLC|SEM members from all around Utah converged on  [Hotel Monaco](http://www.monaco-saltlakecity.com/) for the inaugural members-only event. The excitement from the 60+ members in attendance was contagious as they greeted old friends and made some new ones. [![](https://www.utahdmc.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Networking-at-SLC-SEM-1024x682.jpg?width=640&height=426&name=Networking-at-SLC-SEM-1024x682.jpg "Networking at SLC SEM")](http://slcsem.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Networking-at-SLC-SEM.jpg) With Marshall Simmonds ( [@mdsimmonds](http://twitter.com/mdsimmonds)) of [Define Media Group](http://definemg.com/) as the keynote speaker and presentations by local members & experts Rob Johnson ( [@robkellas](http://twitter.com/robkellas)) and Aaron Wester ( [@aaronix](http://twitter.com/aaronix)), of [Deseret Digital Media](http://www.deseretdigital.com), we all knew to get our note pads ready. In case you missed the event, I wanted to give you five takeaways I gained from these awesome speakers. ## 1. Embrace Google Updates, They are Job Security[![](https://www.utahdmc.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Marhsall-sharing-insights-682x1024.jpg?width=384&height=576&name=Marhsall-sharing-insights-682x1024.jpg "Marhsall sharing insights")](http://slcsem.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Marhsall-sharing-insights.jpg) ## Keynote from Marshall Simmonds Marshall talked about how many SEO experts have a knee jerk reaction every time they hear “Google Update.” Instead of almost wanting to cry each time Google makes an update, embrace it. Google will not stop making algorithmic updates; they are a necessary evil, and that will never change. Marshall said, “When Google moves the goal posts, it gives us job security. The Brass, or Executives, will always need people to translate it.” And I couldn’t agree more. He went on to talk about the fact that Panda had been a great motivator to help move SEO initiatives forward that had been on the back burner before. Instead of running for the hills because another update rolls into town, think of it as an opportunity. ## 2.  Work With Search Engines To Maintain The Health of Your Site I don’t have a direct number to Google (shocking, I know), so when something happens to my websites, I can’t just call and get it fixed. From what I have heard, this is a very common occurrence in the SEO industry. What Marshall proposed that we use the data that we are receiving from Google Analytics and (Google, Bing) Webmaster Tools to develop and maintain the health of our websites. Update your sitemaps, and implement structured data ( [Schema.org](http://www.schema.org))  so the search engines know how to index your content. If you have broken links, get them fixed so the search engines can properly index your site. Even look into your server reports and see where the search engines have been on your site. There could be neglected areas you have missed that search spiders are viewing. Work with them on the areas that they report as needing attention. ## 3.  Stand Out in News Search With the Rel=Standout Tag This caught my attention because most of the sites I currently work on are news focused.  Marshall noted that those lucky enough to be accepted into Google News should be excited about and using  [the new Standout Tag Google](http://searchengineland.com/google-news-launches-standout-tag-for-featured-content-94256) released back in September. I have to admit, I am not the best when it comes to reading Google announcements. However, when an expert like Marshall Simmonds mentions something that helps news sites, he has my 100% focus. Many times in our SEO pursuits, I think we all get caught up in things that take our attention away from the “small” things that come out on the Internet. At times, those might be the most important things that could help our sites succeed. ## 4.  Don’t Just Do, Teach! [![](https://www.utahdmc.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Sharing-hard-earned-tips-1024x682.jpg?width=448&height=298&name=Sharing-hard-earned-tips-1024x682.jpg "Sharing hard earned tips")](http://slcsem.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Sharing-hard-earned-tips.jpg) The local DDM team of Rob Johnson & Aaron Wester went into depth about their work with KSL and some of their struggles helping journalists see the importance of SEO. As the news agency became more focused on digital media,, there were some feelings among the journalists of "digital being the devil." The DDM team was looking for an opportunity to help the journalists understand their new audience in the digital world. Working with trending topics gave them the perfect opportunity to teach SEO to the journalists. They developed training that pointed out why the journalists were not reaching their audience effectively. They worked with journalists to show them the reasons articles need an SEO focus to help capture their audience. By taking the time to teach instead of doing it themselves, they helped improve the overall site performance. ## 5.  Walk the Line With Online Journalism Again, the DDM team caught my attention with this question:  *Where do you draw the line between optimized content and quality?* Since I work for a digital publisher, this really hit home because this seems like a daily battle with our writers. What the DDM team suggested was to find ways to teach the importance of SEO without requiring writers to overly focus on SEO. If you only pound *SEO, SEO, SEO* into the poor writers heads, they will start losing the creative latitude to be able to capture their readers. Let them do their jobs and sprinkle their content with best practices, don’t handcuff them so they don’t even know where to start. **[SEO Adoption @ DDM SLC|SEM Nov 16](http://www.slideshare.net/robkellas/seo-adoption-ddm-slcsem-nov-16)** View more [presentations](http://www.slideshare.net/) from [Rob Johnson](http://www.slideshare.net/robkellas) ## The Bottom Line In my opinion, the SLC|SEM event was a huge success: great people, amazing food, and information you can’t get that anywhere else in Utah. Post your top takeaways from the event in the comments below! It is also great to see the SEO community starting to connect and to be able to put some names to faces.  (You can see the all the photos from the event on the [SLC|SEM Facebook Page](http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.168018456627077.36615.149767721785484&type=1).) Thanks goes out to the SLC|SEM team for making it happen. If you haven't yet [joined SLC|SEM as a member](https://www.slcsem.org/membership/), you should! It's the best way to make sure you'll get a seat at upcoming events - as members get priority seating, there may not always be space available for non-members. (December will be a casual, holiday party style meetup for search marketers - date, venue TBA soon. In January, Bing.com comes to talk about [video search](http://www.bing.com/videos/) & user consumption of online video, and in February, [Danny Sullivan of Search Engine Land](http://searchengineland.com/author/danny-sullivan) will be speaking to the crowd of Utah search marketers.) I will see you at upcoming events! **About the Author: ** Devin Doxey is an entrepreneur at heart with wicked programming and SEO skills that have lead him to  [TechMedia Network](http://www.techmedianetwork.com/) where he is currently an SEO Marketer. At TMN, Devin monitors over 20 sites, selectively choosing keywords and strategies that bring in over 20 million unique viewers each month. He can be found on Twitter at  [@dhdoxey](http://twitter.com/dhdoxey) and/or on  [Google Plus](https://plus.google.com/114491782516391215926/posts). Topics: [News](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/news) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ### About Our Blog This is where you find event recaps, guest blog posts, and other newsworthy items from Utah DMC. ### Subscribe to the Utah DMC Blog ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [Event Recaps (113)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/event-recaps) - [Events (40)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/events) - [strategy (24)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/strategy) - [ppc (23)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/ppc) - [DMC (22)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/dmc) - [News (21)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/news) - [digital marketing utah (21)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/digital-marketing-utah) - [DMC2018 (16)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/dmc2018) - [Blog (15)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/blog) - [DMC2016 (12)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/dmc2016) - [DMC2017 (12)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/dmc2017) - [marketing (12)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/marketing) - [seo (11)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/seo) - [content marketing (10)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/content-marketing) - [social media (9)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/social-media) - [digital marketing (8)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/digital-marketing) - [data (6)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/data) - [video marketing (6)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/video-marketing) - [analytics (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/analytics) - [artificial intelligence (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/artificial-intelligence) - [facebook (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/facebook) - [paid search (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/paid-search) - [paid social (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/paid-social) - [social media advertising (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/social-media-advertising) - [Google (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/google) - [advertising (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/advertising) - [personal branding (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/personal-branding) - [AdWords (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/adwords) - [Uncategorized (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/uncategorized) - [business (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/business) - [ecommerce (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/ecommerce) - [jobs (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/jobs) - [sem (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/sem) - [social media optimization (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/social-media-optimization) - [Display Advertising (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/display-advertising) - [Guest Post (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/guest-post) - [Members (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/members) - [Programmatic Display Advertising (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/programmatic-display-advertising) - [SEM trends (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/sem-trends) - [Videos (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/videos) - [YouTube (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/youtube) - [agency (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/agency) - [attribution (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/attribution) - [automation (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/automation) - [content (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/content) - [facebook funnels (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/facebook-funnels) - [job searching (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/job-searching) - [quora (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/quora) - [seo tips (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/seo-tips) - [slc meetups (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/slc-meetups) - [slc|sem (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/slcsem) - [snapchat (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/snapchat) - [CMO (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/cmo) - [CRO (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/cro) - [Community (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/community) - [Dungeons & Dragons (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/dungeons-dragons) - [Facebook Ads (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/facebook-ads) - [Ginny Marvin (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/ginny-marvin) - [Google trends (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/google-trends) - [Google, algorithm, Ted Waz, SLCSEM, DMC (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/google-algorithm-ted-waz-slcsem-dmc) - [Growth (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/growth) - [Hiring (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/hiring) - [James Svoboda (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/james-svoboda) - [John doherty (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/john-doherty) - [Justin Rondeau (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/justin-rondeau) - [PR (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/pr) - [Remarketing (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/remarketing) - [Sales (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/sales) - [Survey (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/survey) - [Virtual Events (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/virtual-events) - [West Barnell (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/west-barnell) - [aaron levy (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/aaron-levy) - [branding (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/branding) - [buzzstream (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/buzzstream) - [casie gillette (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/casie-gillette) - [chat bots (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/chat-bots) - [christi olson (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/christi-olson) - [conversion rate optimization (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/conversion-rate-optimization) - [crawling (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/crawling) - [customer experience (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/customer-experience) - [education (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/education) - [events (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/events-2) - [facebook messenger (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/facebook-messenger) - [google data studio (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/google-data-studio) - [googlebots (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/googlebots) - [hubspot (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/hubspot) - [impressions (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/impressions) - [influencer marketing (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/influencer-marketing) - [influencers (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/influencers) - [joe martin (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/joe-martin) - [lead genereation (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/lead-genereation) - [linkbuilding (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/linkbuilding) - [machine learning (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/machine-learning) - [marketing automation (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/marketing-automation) - [marty weintraub (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/marty-weintraub) - [micro moments (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/micro-moments) - [mobile (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/mobile) - [networking (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/networking) - [networking events (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/networking-events) - [online marketing (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/online-marketing) - [reporting (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/reporting) - [roi (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/roi) - [search (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/search) - [social (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/social) - [utah (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/utah) - [visual sale (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/topic/visual-sale) see all ### Blog Archive - [September 2015 (18)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/09) - [October 2018 (17)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/10) - [November 2017 (16)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/11) - [September 2019 (16)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2019/09) - [January 2017 (7)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/01) - [October 2016 (6)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/10) - [January 2020 (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/01) - [July 2020 (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/07) - [December 2021 (5)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2021/12) - [November 2011 (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2011/11) - [January 2012 (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/01) - [May 2017 (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/05) - [October 2017 (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/10) - [August 2019 (4)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2019/08) - [October 2011 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2011/10) - [February 2012 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/02) - [October 2014 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/10) - [September 2016 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/09) - [April 2019 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2019/04) - [September 2020 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/09) - [November 2020 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/11) - [March 2021 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2021/03) - [July 2021 (3)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2021/07) - [December 2011 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2011/12) - [March 2012 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/03) - [April 2012 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/04) - [July 2012 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/07) - [September 2012 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/09) - [November 2012 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/11) - [February 2013 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/02) - [March 2013 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/03) - [April 2013 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/04) - [July 2013 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/07) - [September 2013 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/09) - [August 2014 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/08) - [February 2015 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/02) - [May 2015 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/05) - [August 2015 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/08) - [February 2018 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/02) - [April 2018 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/04) - [December 2018 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/12) - [June 2020 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/06) - [December 2020 (2)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/12) - [June 2012 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/06) - [August 2012 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/08) - [December 2012 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2012/12) - [January 2013 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/01) - [May 2013 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/05) - [June 2013 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/06) - [November 2013 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/11) - [December 2013 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2013/12) - [January 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/01) - [February 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/02) - [March 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/03) - [May 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/05) - [June 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/06) - [July 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/07) - [September 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/09) - [December 2014 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2014/12) - [March 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/03) - [April 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/04) - [June 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/06) - [October 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/10) - [November 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/11) - [December 2015 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2015/12) - [January 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/01) - [March 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/03) - [April 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/04) - [May 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/05) - [June 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/06) - [August 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/08) - [December 2016 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2016/12) - [June 2017 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/06) - [August 2017 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2017/08) - [March 2018 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/03) - [June 2018 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/06) - [July 2018 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/07) - [August 2018 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2018/08) - [February 2019 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2019/02) - [March 2020 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/03) - [August 2020 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2020/08) - [May 2021 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2021/05) - [June 2021 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2021/06) - [October 2022 (1)](https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/archive/2022/10) see all ### Contact **SLC|SEM DBA Utah Digital Marketing Collective** Salt Lake City, Utah  ### From Our Blog ### Subscribe to updates ### Connect With Us © 2026 Utah DMC / SLCSEM ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "kacieeugenia819", "url" : "https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/author/kacieeugenia819" }, "datePublished" : "2011-11-17T00:30:16.000Z", "headline" : "November Event Recap: 5 Takeaways For Content Teams & SEO's ", "image" : [ "https://www.utahdmc.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Networking-at-SLC-SEM-1024x682.jpg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.utahdmc.org/blog/2011/11/november-event-recap-5-takeaways-for-content-teams-seos", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://www.utahdmc.org/hubfs/Utah%20DMC%20Logo.png" }, "name" : "Utah Digital Marketing Collective" } } ```